Car Insurance Tampa - Best Quotes - Cheap Rates - from Your Local Experts

Finding the right coverage in Hillsborough County isn’t just about clicking a button; it’s about finding a partner who understands the unique risks we face on I-275 and across the Bay Area. For over 35 years, Colucci Insurance has been your trusted, local expert for car insurance in Tampa.

Unlike big box websites that treat you like a number, we are real people—your neighbors—dedicated to protecting your family and your assets. Because we are an independent agent, we don’t work for just one insurance company; we work for you. This allows us to compare policies from multiple top-rated providers to find you the best car insurance company in Tampa, Florida for your specific needs.

Whether you have a perfect driving record or need a helping hand, we do the heavy lifting to ensure you get the lowest rates possible without sacrificing coverage.

See why our clients trust us: Check out our Better Business Bureau Profile to verify our A+ rating, local expertise, and commitment to trustworthy service.

For quotes Call 813-972-1947 or fill out our easy to use quote form 24 hours a day: Car Insurance Quotes Tampa 

Many drivers ask us, “How can I get cheap car insurance in Tampa without losing important coverage?” The answer is choice.

When you call a “captive” agent (one who represents a single big-name brand), they can only offer you one price. If that price is high, you’re out of luck. At Colucci Insurance, we shop the market for you. We provide car insurance quotes in Tampa from dozens of carriers, forcing them to compete for your business. This is the most effective way to secure cheapest car insurance quotes in Tampa while ensuring you are actually protected when you need it most.

To legally drive in Tampa, you must carry the state minimum coverage. Florida is a “No-Fault” state, which simplifies how medical bills are paid but makes carrying the right coverage essential.

At a minimum, you must carry:

• Personal Injury Protection (PIP): $10,000 minimum. This covers 80% of your medical bills and 60% of lost wages after an accident, regardless of who was at fault.

• Property Damage Liability (PDL): $10,000 minimum. This pays for damage you cause to other people’s property (such as their vehicle or a fence) in a crash.

While these are the minimums required to get a tag, they often aren’t enough to fully protect your financial future. We can help you decide if higher limits or additional coverages—like Uninsured Motorist protection—are right for you.

Specialized Coverage Needs: If you have specific filing requirements, we are here to help. We specialize in helping drivers get back on the road legally.

• Visit our Florida SR22 Insurance page for details on reinstatement.

• Visit our Florida FR44 Insurance page if you require high-liability filings for DUI convictions.

The car insurance cost in Tampa varies widely based on your age, driving history, credit score, and zip code. While Tampa rates are generally higher than the national average due to traffic density and weather risks, we help offset this by shopping your policy. Contact us for a personalized breakdown.

There is no single “cheapest” company for everyone. One carrier might offer the lowest rate for a single driver in Ybor City, while another is better for a family in New Tampa. To save on car insurance in Tampa, the best way is to contact independent agents such as Colucci Insurance. We can provide multiple quotes from the best car insurance companies in Tampa, ensuring you find the carrier that favors your specific profile.

The “best” insurance combines affordability with reliability. You can find it right here at Colucci Insurance. We vet the carriers we work with to ensure they have strong financial stability and claims service, so you aren’t left stranded after an accident.

Yes. We understand that mistakes happen. We offer non-judgmental, fast service to help you file specialized SR22 and FR44 insurance forms required by the state to reinstate your license.

• Bundle Policies: Combine your auto and homeowners insurance.

• Increase Deductibles: Willingness to pay more out-of-pocket for a claim can lower your monthly premium.

• Shop Around: Let an independent agent requote your policy annually.

• Maintain Good Credit: In Florida, your credit score can influence your rate.

Once you have your insurance proof from us, you must register your vehicle. For informaiton on car registrations in the state visit the FLHSMV Car Registration Page, however to register your car locally you must go to the Hillsborough County Tax Collector.

Local Tax Collector Addresses:

• Downtown: 601 E Kennedy Blvd, Tampa, FL 33602

• North Tampa: 3011 University Center Dr, Suite 150, Tampa, FL 33612

• East Tampa: 2814 E Hillsborough Avenue, Tampa FL 33610

• Drew Park: 4100 West Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard, Tampa FL 33614

• Brandon: 3030 N Falkenburg Rd, Tampa, FL 33619

• Plant City: 4706 Sydney Rd, Plant City, FL 33566
• SouthShore: 406 30th Street SE, Ruskin, FL 33570

While we call Tampa home, we help drivers find affordable coverage all over the Sunshine State.

• • Temple Terrace Car Insurance – Lutz Car Insurance – Land O Lakes Car Insurance – Odessa Car Insurance – Oldsmar Car Insurance – Wesley Chapel Car Insurance   
  • Zephyrhills Car Insurance – Dade City Car Insurance – Brooksville Car Insurance – Thonotosassa Car Insurance – Brandon Car Insurance – Riverview Car Insurance   
  • Plant City Car Insurance – Lakeland Car Insurance – Orlando Car Insurance – New Port Richey Car Insurance – Clearwater Car Insurance – St Petersburg Car Insurance   
  • Bradenton Car Insurance –  Sarasota Car Insurance – Cape Coral Car Insurance – Fort Myers Car Insurance – Ocala Car Insurance – Gainesville Car Insurance
  • Tallahassee Car Insurance – Pensacola Car Insurance – Jacksonville Car Insurance – Fort Lauderdale Car Insurance – Miami Car Insurance  

Stop Overpaying for Auto Insurance Today!

Don’t settle for high rates or impersonal service. Let the local experts with over 35 years of experience fight for your wallet.

Call Colucci Insurance Now: 813-972-1947

Get Your Free Quote